Skip navigation

Intermittent starting issue with 20vt APY conversion...confused

Post

Back to the top
Hi all,

Having a starting issue with my ko4 20vt APY conversion I need some help with :S Below is a description of what's going on, and I can't figure out the cause…

29th August:
Drove the car about 40 miles, no problems. Started first time, ran perfectly, no issues. Stopped at my destination and left the car sitting (not running) for probably around 30 minutes. Went to start the car again and nothing. The engine turned, but nothing fired. I usually turn the key to first position to prime the in-line fuel pump, and it usually makes a little whine when I do this and I take that to mean it's primed, then I turn to second position and fire the engine. This time though, turning to first position would only rarely produce the little whine from the in-line pump. So, I checked the pump and the wiring was a little dodgy, bad crimp on the positive terminal. So, got the car towed to a nearby friends and left it there for 5 days while I went back home to get necessary tools etc.

2nd September:
Re-crimped the terminals and reconnected to the fuel pump. Turned the key and started first time, ran perfectly, left to idle for a few minutes and no problems at all. Great, I thought, all solved.

3rd September:
Started the car again in the morning, no issues at all, drove about 50 miles. Halfway through stopped to re-fuel, again, no problems with restarting the car. Got to my destination, again left the car for about 30 minutes, tried to restart. First position, heard the whine, but then the car wouldn't start again… Exactly the same symptoms as last time…

So, I'm confused. The engine turns over, sometimes splutters up to 500rpm and then stalls out, sometimes just cranks and cranks with nothing. I'm going to try leaving the car for a few hours and try starting again.

Thought maybe a hot start issue…but then it fired fine after stopping at the petrol station for a few minutes. Quite confused…Recently my Forge DV has started to "flutter" when dumping boost, don't know if connected at all.

Confused, would appreciate help with fault finding a bit.

Cheers,
Aran

Post

Back to the top
where is the fuel relay mounted, and what number is it?  also what fusebox?

Hello my name is John and I'm a dub addict.



My wiring diagrams and other documents have moved here:

VAG Documents & Downloads

You'll need to sign into google/gmail for the link to work! (its free!)

Post

Back to the top
Believe it's mounted under the passenger glovebox along with the fuse-box (but I haven't had a good look). It's running OEM management, so I imagine it will be a 409 relay.

I've also been advised it could simply be the water temp sensor, sending dodgy signals to the ECU and not allowing the car to start after it's been for a run and not cooled down yet

Post

Back to the top
ok well let us know what you discover. if its been wired oem then you could replace the 409 with a 67, 80 or 167.

but sometimes if the relay has been put above the fusebox the wiring looms are made a bit strange so they will only work with a 409 fitted

Hello my name is John and I'm a dub addict.



My wiring diagrams and other documents have moved here:

VAG Documents & Downloads

You'll need to sign into google/gmail for the link to work! (its free!)

Post

Back to the top
Thanks. I'd probably just replace like for like if it came to it, avoid any problems. I hate intermittent faults…

Post

Back to the top
crank position sensor

Post

Back to the top
Ok, so an update on this:

- I found a boost leak causing a flutter, fixed
- I replaced the coolant temp sensor and crank pos sensor
- Scanned the car and no faults
- Took the car for a road trip for about 500 miles this weekend, and when running, the engine feels great. However, again when sitting for about 10 minutes it will fire and then immediately die unless I leave the car to cool off for about 50 minutes
- I noticed a bit of pink around the coolant bottle, and it seems like perhaps the coolant is actually getting way too hot when I leave the car at a standstill after a drive. Seems to me that it's actually boiling and seeping out of the cap at the top of the coolant bottle. Then when I try to start the car it won't because the coolant is so hot, and it needs to cool down. I "think" this sounds consistent with the issue, but happy to get your thoughts.

I'm going to get some more coolant in the system and check for air locks, see if simply there isn't enough coolant running round the system. Then perhaps a timer to keep the coolant running for a time after shutting off? To be honest though, it shouldn't be overheating given it's a modern engine.

Post

Back to the top
id start by replacing the cap, perhaps the pressure valve inside has gone. if the tank vents too early the system wont be able to fully pressurise which could lead to the coolant boiling up and giving you air locks

the waterpump on the 20v known for failign as well so thats worth a look, plus worth doing a full checkover of the coolant system:
http://www.clubgti.com/showthread.php?145091

Hello my name is John and I'm a dub addict.



My wiring diagrams and other documents have moved here:

VAG Documents & Downloads

You'll need to sign into google/gmail for the link to work! (its free!)

Post

Back to the top
I just had the waterpump / belt changed a couple months ago, so that should be all good.

It's got an aftermarket coolant bottle in the car which I've never liked really, so I'm thinking about changing it back to standard, something I can trust

Post

Back to the top
Re-starting this old thread. Took the car out today and the same issue hapenned once more. I noticed red residue on the coolant bottle top after the car had been standing for a while (and then wouldn't start)…so I think we're definitely getting boiling coolant here!

I've replaced the coolant temp sensor, thermostat, water pump and reflushed whole system and I'm still getting this issue of the coolant boiling, not great.

So I'm thinking (as RubJonny says) to replace the coolant bottle back to an OEM one from the S3 in case the cap is loose, not allowing the system to pressurize etc.

But other than doing this and refilling the system, andthing else to check / change?
0 guests and 0 members have just viewed this: None.